News

The truth prevails yet again as AMP takes another win in federal court

Statements

A federal court in Georgia dismissed a lawsuit against American Muslims for Palestine (AMP) yesterday, ruling that the plaintiff's accusations were not supported by facts. The case, pending since April 2025, was dismissed after the plaintiff filed an initial complaint and amended it twice.

In its ruling, the court explained that the plaintiff's allegations were largely conclusions rather than factual claims and therefore could not be assumed to be true. The plaintiff argued that AMP should be held responsible for others' statements and actions. However, the court agreed with AMP's attorneys that the complaint offered no factual basis for holding AMP responsible. Simply making an accusation, the court made clear, does not make it true.

Christina Jump of Jump Start Legal Justice Center led AMP's legal team to this victory, along with co-counsel Samira Elhosary of Muslim Legal Fund of America and James Slater of Slater Legal PLLC.

"This makes the fifth federal court to dismiss litigation against AMP as unsubstantiated," observed Christina Jump.  "Courts recognize that at some point, plaintiffs need more than just rhetoric and beliefs to maintain a lawsuit.  And here, the plaintiff came up empty."

Dr. Osama Abu Irshaid, AMP Executive Director, stated that "Today's ruling is yet another affirmation that courts are guided by facts and evidence, not by unfounded allegations or manufactured assumptions. Our opponents are free to advance speculative theories and false narratives, but conjecture cannot survive judicial scrutiny when it is unsupported by evidence.”

“Over the years, AMP has faced numerous meritless and politically motivated lawsuits, and we have prevailed in many of them. We remain confident that the remaining cases will meet the same fate, not only because we believe we stand on the right side of history, but because our legal position is clear, strong, and grounded in verifiable facts rather than rhetoric or false claims.”

“We are deeply grateful to Christina Jump and the team at Jump Start Legal Justice Center, as well as Samira Elhosary and the Muslim Legal Fund of America, for their unwavering support, perseverance, and exceptional legal work in securing this important victory. Their dedication to justice and the rule of law has been instrumental in defending AMP against these baseless claims.”

"Today’s ruling confirms what we have said from the start: AMP cannot be held responsible for statements it did not make, based on a relationship the plaintiff simply assumed," commented Samira Elhosary, Senior Staff Attorney at MLFA. "The Court refused to let speculation stand in for evidence. We are proud to stand with AMP and its right to do its work without being dragged into baseless litigation."

No amount of baseless accusations, intimidation, or attempts to silence us will deter our commitment to Palestinian freedom and liberation. We will continue to speak out, organize, and fight for an end to U.S. complicity in Israel's occupation of the Palestinian people. Onwards.